On Apr 10, 2017, at 3:04 PM, Paul Offord <Paul.Offord@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>> If a tree isn't being generated, because it isn't necessary (e.g., if the code calling the dissectors is only trying to get the column contents) there's presumably no need for TRANSUM - or any other dissector or post-dissector - to add anything to the non-existent tree.
>
> Agreed, except in the case of TRANSUM the user will probably want to add a TRANSUM-computed value as a column. For example, if you use tshark to just output the Packet List entries (summary lines) it's likely that TRANSUM-computed values would be included in that listing.
That's not a TRANSUM-specific issue. If the user wants to use *any* custom columns, from *any* dissector or post-dissector field, the protocol tree currently has to be generated - and, given that custom columns work, we *already* arrange to construct the protocol tree whenever we're asking for columns and at least one column is a custom column (see various calls to have_custom_cols()), so if the code calling the dissectors is only trying to get the column contents *but* at least one column is a custom column, the tree will be constructed.
